Comments are marginalized in the blogosphere

Something that I’ve noticed for quite a while, and given some thought to, is that blog comments seem to be the most marginalized element of the blogosphere. This, in spite of the fact that in many cases, a comment may be even more useful or valuable than the original posting on which it is based. Of course most up to date blogging software platforms not only provide commenting capability but also allow you to present a separate RSS feed for the comments. Some blogs, such as the LITA Blog, take this a step further and combine postings and associated comments into a single, integrated RSS feed. I wish I could figure out how to do that with this blog because I like that approach. Why then do I think comments are marginalized? Well, because I suspect most people, like me, either do not subscribe to a separate comment feed or don’t know that one exists for a particular blog, so a lot of the discussion on an interesting topic is missed. Some blogs offer the ability to subscribe to a feed just for comments on one particular posting. But let’s be honest, how many of us are willing to add umpteen RSS feed subscriptions to our news aggregator in the hopes of keeping up with what might be an interesting conversation? Even worse, comments do not seem to be readily accessible via search engines, including blog search engines such as Google’s Blog Search or technorati. Furthermore, while blog posts tend to have several choices for tagging as ways to help navigate or find related postings, comments simply muddle along with the vast majority of them having no such capability. (I think I have seen the ability to tag comments on one or two sites, but I could just be imagining it.)

What can or should be done? Well, blog comments need to stand up for their rights, for one thing. They need to advertise their existence more (be readily searchable in or exposed to search engines). They need to organize (implement tagging or related technologies to enhance findability and navigation). They need to find new and easier ways to get their message across without the clutter of trackbacks.

The last paragraph in particular is written a bit tongue in cheek. However…Is this a non issue? Has it already been addressed? Am I making a mountain out of a mole hill (as my mother often said)? Please comment.

Changes to this blog

After reading Jakob Nielsen’s Top Ten Weblog Design Mistakes (an excellent list), I decided to make some long overdue changes to this blog. In the sidebar, I added an About Me portion containing my photo and some other information. I also reordered some of the sidebar elements so that a new Subscribe section was nearer the top. This section contains the RSS and comments RSS links as well as a form to input your email address if you prefer to be notified of blog updates via email instead of RSS. I also added a new Recent Photos section that highlights the five most recent photos from my Flickr account. If you click on one of these photos you will be able to peruse all of the photo albums I’ve currently uploaded to Flickr without having to leave this blog. Finally, I just read this a.m. about a new Bible verse of the day plugin for WordPress so I decided to add that into the sidebar as well.

New blog features

I just finished adding some features to this blog. One is the addition of online status indicators for the three IM accounts that I regularly use: AIM, Yahoo! Messenger, and MSN Messenger. If you see one or more of these icons show that I’m online, just click on the one for the IM service you use and that way we can have a chat. I’d love to hear from you! Another feature I’ve added is the ability for others to syndicate the comments for this site (see the new link for this under the XML / RSS Feed portion of the righthand navigation menu). One addition I’m hoping to make sometime soon is something like what my friend Emily has done with her blog: add a section displaying small images of the books I’m currently reading. What do others find useful as blog features in this or other blogs? Not useful? Give me your comments so that I can try to improve this whole thing.

Teenagers and weblogs

My mother told me about this article on BBC News about teenagers and weblogs. It discusses research about teenage bloggers. For example, in terms of a gender breakdown, research shows that the split is about 50/50. It also discusses why blogs are wildly popular among teens and the ways in which they are being used, e.g. as a form of self-therapy. One interesting quote, from a professor at Georgetown University: “The average blog post is about 2,000 words, which is really interesting when you are trying to get kids to write essays.” In other words, blogs are demonstrating that teens are willing to write, and that they are willing to write much more than expected. A few other interesting study results: 67% tend to use the comments feature; teens tend to be perhaps a bit too revealing about personal details in blogs, more so than in chat rooms; and male bloggers have more of a tendency to reveal details about their location, whereas female bloggers tend to link to their personal webpages.

What are implications for libraries of teenagers’ interest in blogging? I think there are several. One obvious one is that we must be aware of this socio-cultural phenomenon. Incoming students at the university level likely are familiar and comfortable with blogs already. We can appeal to them by using this medium of expression in ways that will be attractive and familiar to them. The article mentioned above makes reference to some teachers using blogs to foster peer-review among students, which to me, fits like a glove with the increasing emphasis at my university and others, on group study and collaborative work. We need to think of ways in which to use blogs to foster this kind of connectivity with the library, not just as an information delivery tool, but as a tool for collaboration with students. Incoming students using the library may expect the ability to have more input and participation in services and programs of the library, and we need to allow them — perhaps via blogs and/or other means — the means to do that. Otherwise, they may be turned off or more easily dissatisfied with their interactions with the library. I think it also goes without saying that libraries, mine included, exist largely in a virtual environment. Many of our students are using library resources without ever (or seldom) visiting the physical library. I struggle with this all the time because I think it’s very important that the online library presence or environment be as easy and inviting to use as possible. Blogs may be one of the more important tools for achieving that goal.

Sometimes I feel a bit ahead of the curve on this one (importance of and excitement with blogging) in terms of my local environment. Then I read an article like this and it serves to confirm what I’ve been thinking. Thanks, Mother, for pointing this article out to me!