Something that I’ve noticed for quite a while, and given some thought to, is that blog comments seem to be the most marginalized element of the blogosphere. This, in spite of the fact that in many cases, a comment may be even more useful or valuable than the original posting on which it is based. Of course most up to date blogging software platforms not only provide commenting capability but also allow you to present a separate RSS feed for the comments. Some blogs, such as the LITA Blog, take this a step further and combine postings and associated comments into a single, integrated RSS feed. I wish I could figure out how to do that with this blog because I like that approach. Why then do I think comments are marginalized? Well, because I suspect most people, like me, either do not subscribe to a separate comment feed or don’t know that one exists for a particular blog, so a lot of the discussion on an interesting topic is missed. Some blogs offer the ability to subscribe to a feed just for comments on one particular posting. But let’s be honest, how many of us are willing to add umpteen RSS feed subscriptions to our news aggregator in the hopes of keeping up with what might be an interesting conversation? Even worse, comments do not seem to be readily accessible via search engines, including blog search engines such as Google’s Blog Search or technorati. Furthermore, while blog posts tend to have several choices for tagging as ways to help navigate or find related postings, comments simply muddle along with the vast majority of them having no such capability. (I think I have seen the ability to tag comments on one or two sites, but I could just be imagining it.)
What can or should be done? Well, blog comments need to stand up for their rights, for one thing. They need to advertise their existence more (be readily searchable in or exposed to search engines). They need to organize (implement tagging or related technologies to enhance findability and navigation). They need to find new and easier ways to get their message across without the clutter of trackbacks.
The last paragraph in particular is written a bit tongue in cheek. However…Is this a non issue? Has it already been addressed? Am I making a mountain out of a mole hill (as my mother often said)? Please comment.